Hogarthian or Bogarthian
As far as cave diving goes, most of the divers are using what we call a backmounted Hogarthian configuration. Named after it’s founding father William Hogarth Main, the Hogarthian gear configuration is constantly being improved and copied. As I like to say, it is like a bonsai tree that needs pruning and caring but will live hundreds of years! Even under the ever growing diver population and dilution of knowledge, the core principles of the Hogarthian philosophy stay the same. The current most ‘hard core’ compliant are the members of the WKPP (Wakulla Karst Plan Project) in Florida. Another acronym goes for this gear configuration is DIR or ‘Doing it Right’, as if any other diver not following this philosophy is obviously not doing it right! In fairness to them, the result of such a configuration comes from thousands of dives in a very hostile environment, the caves, at depth greater than 300 feet. So in this aspect of diving, I’d say they know what they are talking about but this does not leave much room for creation and change.
Living in what we like to call the Cave Diving Capital of the world, you see most divers applying the DIR principles but there is a group, irreducible romans maybe (see comic book Asterix and the Gaelic), who are diving with tanks on their sides with no back plate and barely enough lift on their BCD to bring them back out of a deep section of a cave. They call themselves, sidemount divers or solo cave diver or solo explorers. In brief, they are hard core of the hard core divers, ‘crème de la crème’ as we say in French.. During cave exploration it happens a lot that passages are too small to go through with a backmounted set of doubles and also, the buddy principle cannot apply as it may put the lead diver in danger, obstructing the exit or causing a ‘silt-out’, you name it!
The main differences in these two configuration are the tank valves and the way they are distributed. A sidemount diver has two totally independent tanks with a direct access to the valves in case of need, whereas a backmount diver has his valves connected via an isolator valve, the isolator manifold. It allows the diver who has a valve failure or first stage failure, to isolate the tanks and keep half of his gas supply safe.
From this point of view the concept of best redundancy tends to go to the sidemount diver as he has two independent tanks and has many options available in case of first stage or valve failure…
More on this topic later.